Tuesday, July 10, 2012

From the Rhine to the Ohio: the Odyssey of Philip Hollenbach

From the knowledge Philip Hollenbach demonstrated about German wines, we can assume that, born in Germany in 1851, he grew up not far from the vineyards of the Rhine River.  At the age of 18 in 1869 he emigrated to the United States on a journey that would take him to the banks of the Ohio River at Louisville, Kentucky,  where he forged a highly successful career in the liquor trade.

When Hollenbach first arrived on American shores,  he likely had a background in wine making.   His initial stop was in Alabama where for a year he was involved in tending vineyards for a local winery.  After a year he sought new horizons and moved to Louisville.  Hollenbach claimed 1871 as the year of his initiation into the beverage trade, leading me to believe he worked for a Louisville wine and spirits shop, perhaps securing employment by his knowledge of wines.

Within three years Philip had accumulated enough wealth to start a family.  That year in Louisville he married Karolina Jenne, like himself a German immigrant.  They would have three children, Carrie, Louis and Philip.  In 1878, he teamed up with his brother, Louis, to begin his own wholesale liquor business.  Under the name Hollenbach Bros., the company initially was located at 193 Market Street near Sixth, later moving to 101 West Market Street.

Hollenbach Bros. were wholesalers and whiskey blenders.  Like others rectifiers, Philip and Louis apparently had difficulty getting sufficient raw product from area distilleries.  As a result, in 1882 they took charge of the Glencoe Distillery, located at 2540 Broadway in Louisville. That plant had a mashing capability of 160 bushels of grain per day, fully sufficient to keep Hollenbach Bros. in whiskey for blending purposes.  The distillery had been built in 1872 by Frederick and Philip Stitzel. The Hollenbachs kept the Stitzels in charge of the distilling operation.  Their flagship brand became Glencoe Whiskey, promoted widely on trade cards and advertisements. 

When fire razed the Glencoe Distillery in 1883, it was quickly rebuilt. An 1892 insurance record described the new distillery to be of frame construction.  The facility also included cattle pens located 79 feet south of the still and three warehouses.  One warehouse was constructed of brick with a metal or slate roof and the other two were clad in metal sheeting.

About 1885 Philip’s brother Louis left the partnership. Louis subsequently purchased and operated a wholesale and retail whiskey and wine business in Chicago on LaSalle Street near Madison.  The break must have been amicable since Louis was listed as the sole agent selling Glencoe Whiskey in Chicago and all Western states.  Within a short time  Philip Hollenbach took a new partner,  a man named Vetter who had been a Louisville city marshal.  Vetter was described in a local journal as “an excellent and popular businessman and a valuable acquisition.”

The company, now named Hollenbach & Vetter, moved to 234 Second Street.  According to accounts their building was four stories in height,  enjoyed street frontage of 24 feet and a depth of 100 feet.  It was said to have a commodious cellar and was well stocked with liquor and wines, both in barrels and in cases of bottles.  The firm claimed to stock, in addition to its house Glencoe Brand, all well-known Kentucky whiskeys.

The partnership with Vetter proved to be short-lived.  By 1888 Hollenbach was the sole proprietor and the firm name changed again, becoming Phil Hollenbach & Co.  By 1887, Hollenbach was claiming a second distillery called the “Fortuna Distillery.” In ensuing years, Glencoe Whiskey became less and less prominent in company advertising and Fortuna Whiskey became Hollenbach’s flagship brand.  As shown here this whiskey was featured on trade cards,  the company logo, mini-jugs,  back of the bar bottles, and other giveaway items. 

Although accounts differ widely I believe at some time in the early 1900s,  Hollenbach divested himself of part or all of his  interest in the Glencoe Distillery, which subsequently was sold to the Weller distilling family. That facility continued to produce Hollenbach brands such as Fortuna, Pride of the West and Glencoe.  A 1911 ad indicated that Hollenbach was claiming proprietorship of only the Fortuna Distillery.  Assuming Federal records are complete, a distillery of that name never really existed except for Hollenbach merchandising purposes.

Meanwhile, Philip was being recognized as a leader of the liquor industry in Louisville. In 1908, as president of the German-American Alliance of Louisville, representing some thirty or forty German societies, he led an effort for an anti-Prohibition demonstration.  Joining with other organizations, including Irish-American societies, they created a new pressure group, called the Civic League of Kentucky, to fight the “Dry” forces. During this period Hollenbach once again moved his establishment, in 1911 relocating a final time to 528 West Main Street,  along Louisville’s famed “Whiskey Row.”

Philip had been recognized in Louisville for his expertise on German wines and in 1914 was asked to supply a chapter for a book published there on alcoholic and other beverages.  Apparently harking back to his own youth on the banks of the Rhine,  Hollenbach noted that bards of old had been inspired to sing the praise of German wines.  He went on to recommend them heartily to the American drinking public.

In 1920 Prohibition ended the days of Phil. Hollenbach & Company. The Glencoe distillery similarly was shut and dismantled during the period 1920 to 1935.  Remaining buildingswere used by a broom and mop company and a fruit preserving outfit.  After Prohibition Hollenbach’s son, Louis, is said to have revived the distillery and probably was the source for the post-Prohibition sign shown here for Fortuna Whiskey.  As for Philip Hollenbach,  I have been unable to established his date of death or grave site.  However, for his epitaph, it seems appropriate to end with a poem quoted in Hollenbach’s article on German wines:

        “Drink to the Rhine!  And every coming morrow
        Be mirth and music thine!
        And when we meet a child of care and sorrow,
        We’ll send him to the Rhine.”


  1. Thank you, Mr. Sullivan, for your well-researched and pleasing article. I am Barry Holland (bph719@hotmail.com), the eldest great-great-grandson of the Phil Hollenbach about whom you've written. Though I cannot this moment recall the exact date of his death, "Great Grandpa Hollenbach" died in the late 1920's and is buried at Cave Hill Cemetery with a nice vantage of the lake. His burial site, which I visit regularly, is easy to find but gracefully obscured by a stand of trees. As you face the cemetery's offices, standing on the road to the east, your left shoulder angled to the lake, your right shoulder will be angled toward the stand of trees at the bottom of a knoll. Just up the knoll behind said trees is a large but simple Hollenbach marker. My grandfather is buried there alongside his wife, her sister and other close family, including my grandfather's namesake son.

    1. I just read this article and your comment with interest, Mr.Sullivan and Barry. I was just thinking I should ask Leslie how many generations she was from this Phillip Hollenbach, but I think you just answered that. Happy New Year!

  2. Pam: Thanks for your kind comments. It reminded me that I never adequately thanked Barry Holland for filling me in on the location of Phil Hollenbach's grave. It occurred at a time when my computer crashed and when I got a new one, never retraced my blog comments received when I was down. Hope he see this.

  3. I've just now seen this, Jack (if I may), and appreciate it, though it's not in my nature to be concerend about such things. Very simply, you noted a hole in your research, and I attempted to help fill it. This is part of the process of completing history, after all.

  4. Mr Sullivan, an additional correction to be added would be that Pholip Hollenbach did not marry Carrie Schaich as Carrie was his step daughter through marriage to Karolina Jenne. Karolina was my Great Great Grandmother's sister. In fact, at the Hollenbach gravesite located in Cave Hill, Philip Hollenback, his wife Karolina nee:Jenne and my Great Great Grandparents, August Kammerer and Magdelena nee:Jenne, the two couples rest side-by-side. Carrie Schaich was a daughter from the prior marriage of Karolina Jenne to Andreas Schaich who died the year before Karolina married Philip. I have dates and data if you are interested. As mentioned, I offer corrections merely to fill holes. I have spent some 30 years involved in family and Louisville history. Sometimes new puzzle pieces come to light which can be applied to provide truth and clarity to the past. Enjoyed your write up. Respectfully, Jerry Gramig. jgramig02@gmail.com

  5. Thanks Jerry: I always appreciate kinfolk like you who write to clear up mistakes on my posts. I want to get things right and will make the change. You clearly have done some good research. Glad you liked my piece and thanks for writing.

  6. My pleasure Jack. I appreciate your openness to new information, a new puzzle piece, and just hope it was helpful. I was reviewing your post with one of my 1st cousins and his work associate, a descendant of Phil, a Hollenbach. It is amazing that after all these years that we find our two family branches still connected, descendants of Karolina and Magdelena Jenne, cousins working together in Louisville in current times. All of us taking a look at our connections and the history very much enjoyed the efforts of your research and article. Regards, Jerry Gramig

  7. Jerry: Thanks for your thoughtful note. I much appreciate commentary from descendants of interesting personages like Hollenbach. He obviously did not come into the US a wealthy man but through dint of intelligence and hard work make a life for himself and family.